Best Pizza in Ohio: A Local’s Guide to Top-Rated Slices

1. Mikey’s Late Night Slice

If you ask locals where to grab a memorable pizza after midnight, Mikey’s Late Night Slice comes up every time. The place has this funky, welcoming energy that’s halfway between a dive bar and grandma’s kitchen. You walk in and immediately see folks grabbing blue cheese cups, hot pepper flakes, and arguing over ranch vs. unicorn sauce. Their slices have crisp edges with a flavorful, slightly chewy crust—nothing fancy, just the right amount of comfort and grease.

Here’s what makes Mikey’s stand out:

• Wide range of toppings, including vegan and gluten-free options
• Open until late into the night most days (sometimes past 2 a.m.)
• Slices are sold individually, so you don’t have to buy a whole pie
• Fun atmosphere with music and art on the walls

A lot of their regulars actually own businesses nearby, and I’ve overheard conversations about everything from automotive business brokers to which local business for sale brokers actually call you back. It feels like a pizza spot built for people who want a giant slice and maybe some advice about selling an internet business for sale, all in the same booth.

If you’re wondering, “how long is pizza good for in the fridge,” here’s a quick table to help you out:

Storage Method	Safe Duration
In the fridge	3-4 days
In the freezer	1-2 months

Mikey’s feels like one of those places that keeps your night going when everywhere else is closed, and somehow every visit ends with stories about weird toppings or awkward encounters at the condiment stand. This is genuine late-night Ohio pizza, no frills needed.

2. Dewey’s Pizza

Few Ohio pizzerias are as well-loved as Dewey’s Pizza. This spot is famous for its fresh toppings and a chewy, golden crust that always comes out just right. What catches most people off guard is how every slice balances gooey cheese with bright tomato sauce—never too messy, never too dry.

If you’re planning your first visit, here are a few things not to miss:

• Try the Green Lantern or the Ryan’s Inferno if you like bold flavor.
• Their salads, especially the seasonal ones, are always a good bet to start your meal.
• Open kitchens let you watch the staff hand-toss dough and layer toppings, which adds to the experience if you’re into seeing how things are done.

Here’s a quick look at their customer favorites:

Menu Item	Description	Typical Price
Green Lantern	Garlic, mozzarella, sausage	$13 (small)
Bronx Bomber	All the classic meats	$14 (small)
Ryan’s Inferno	Buffalo chicken, ranch base	$13 (small)

Dewey’s is ideal for anyone craving quality without the fuss. I’ve seen it become a popular after-work hangout for some of my friends who are business brokers and other professionals who need a quick, satisfying meal (without hunting for an internet business for sale on their phone). While Dewey’s isn’t focused on automotive business brokers or business for sale brokers, it’s just the kind of place you’d bring them to for a laid-back pizza night.

Dewey’s Pizza feels like a spot where anyone—families, coworkers, or even folks talking shop about their next big move—can relax over some of the best slices in Ohio.

3. Pizza Cucinova

Pizza Cucinova stands out for its creative, build-your-own pizza bar that lets you pick from a long list of toppings, sauces, and crust styles. You walk in, grab a fresh-made dough, then move down the line adding everything you like—it’s a lot like a pizza version of the sandwich spots everyone knows.

Here’s what you’ll notice about Pizza Cucinova:

• Custom pizzas are fired in a big, open oven in just a few minutes.
• Everyone in your group can get a pie exactly how they want it, which is especially handy if you can never agree on toppings.
• If you’re not in a creative mood, they have a handful of classic combos that always hit the spot.

Size	Price Range	Topping Options
Personal (11″)	$8 – $13	40+
Gluten-Free	+$2 surcharge	Most available

Block out a little extra time at Cucinova because the vibe is casual and you’ll probably end up chatting with the staff (they’re into pizza talk). The place is busy after work and on weekends but lines move fast. If you’re into trying new pizza ideas, you could do worse in Ohio.

Sometimes, you just want pizza exactly your way. Pizza Cucinova makes that possible every single time—you never feel like you have to compromise. Honestly, that makes a difference for some of us. Great for families, date nights, or anyone who loves a fun, personal meal.

Locals mention that Pizza Cucinova has a solid following, and while it’s not a spot you’d see listed by business brokers or on internet business for sale ads (like automotive business brokers might post), it feels like a one-of-a-kind find in the heart of Ohio.

4. Harvest Pizzeria

Harvest Pizzeria is one of those spots in Ohio where you eat a slice, and suddenly you realize why pizza gets people excited. From the moment you walk in, it’s clear they care about what goes into their dough, sauce, and toppings. They put a huge focus on local ingredients, and you can actually taste the freshness in every bite. If you’re looking for something beyond just the usual pizza, Harvest Pizzeria makes every detail matter, from their farm-fresh veggies to their thoughtfully selected cheeses.

Let’s break down what makes Harvest Pizzeria stand out:

• Menu changes with the seasons, always keeping things interesting.
• Crust is thin, chewy, and slightly crisp around the edges.
• Toppings go beyond pepperoni – you’ll find roasted mushrooms, goat cheese, and even smoked provolone.

Here’s a quick look at a few popular pies and their average prices:

Pizza Name	Description	Avg. Price
Spicy Yuma	Chorizo, jalapeños, and chipotle crema	$17
Geary Street	Chicken, bacon, smoked provolone	$18
Basic Margherita	Tomatoes, basil, farm cheese	$15

The vibe is relaxed—think more neighborhood hangout than traditional pizzeria—and they draw a crowd of pizza fans, date nights, and even business brokers grabbing a quick meal. It’s the kind of place you’d recommend to anyone, whether they’re searching for new flavors or scouting for inspiration about running a restaurant. While you probably won’t spot business for sale brokers or automotive business brokers closing a deal over pizza every day, you do get plenty of people catching up over a great meal. And if you happen to hear talk of an internet business for sale at the next table, well, that’s Ohio for you—never a dull moment.

5. Yellow Brick Pizza

Yellow Brick Pizza is a spot people always seem to talk about in Columbus. You walk in and instantly feel like it’s a local favorite—laid-back, welcoming, and the kind of place where you’d happily lose a night swapping stories over a couple of giant slices. The crust at Yellow Brick is something special: chewy in the best way, with just the right bit of crisp. Their menu is full of creative specialty pies, but you can build your own from a big list of toppings too.

If you’re looking for a different take, their Detroit-style pizza, with its thick, edge-to-edge cheesy crust, is worth trying at least once. Vegan and gluten-free eaters won’t feel left out here either—there are plenty of choices. They have sandwiches and salads if someone in your group isn’t in the mood for pizza.

Here’s what stands out most for people trying Yellow Brick Pizza:

• Hand-tossed dough made fresh daily.
• Bold, unique flavor combos (everybody talks about the spicy pepperoni and honey setup).
• Chill, no-rush atmosphere that makes you want to stick around after you eat.

You can tell there’s a small business vibe going, kind of like the relationship most business brokers foster with local entrepreneurs. If you’ve found yourself searching for an internet business for sale or chatting with automotive business brokers in Ohio, Yellow Brick Pizza feels like the kind of place owners and brokers would meet to swap ideas after closing a deal.

Pie Size	Slices	Price Range
Personal	4	$9-$11
Medium	8	$17-$20
Large	12	$22-$28

Whenever I stop by Yellow Brick, I always end up ordering a little more than I planned, just because the options are tempting and the staff genuinely seem glad you’re there. It’s one of those pizza joints that feels honest and real, no frills, just good pie.

6. Adriatico’s New York Style Pizza

Tucked near the Ohio State University campus, Adriatico’s is one of those spots people talk about when you ask where to get true New York style pizza in Ohio. Their crust is thin but still has that chew you want and the sauce is super flavorful—not too sweet, not too heavy. Adriatico’s stands out for their massive, square-cut Sicilian pies as well, a real crowd pleaser for game days or big groups.

Here’s what regulars (including a few business brokers and students in the know) say makes Adriatico’s special:

• Huge pizza sizes, from traditional 12-inch to the Big 30 Cut, perfect for sharing
• Toppings are generous—think double pepperoni, hearty veggies, and extra cheese
• Great spot for casual hangouts, team celebrations, or even quick slices between errands

Pizza Size	Price Range	Number of Slices
Small (12-inch)	$12 – $16	8
Medium (14-inch)	$16 – $20	12
Big 30 Cut	$35 – $40	30

If you’re running late, you can always grab a few slices to go, or just eat on the patio. The vibe is always relaxed, whether you’re a student, an automotive business broker off the clock, or someone just hungry after a long day.

On busy weekends, Adriatico’s feels like a local landmark—people from all walks, business for sale brokers, students, sports fans, you name it, all in for their pizza fix. It’s hard to find another spot that brings folks together this way.

So, if the next search on your phone is “internet business for sale” but you need dinner first, swing by Adriatico’s and see why Columbus locals swear by it.

7. Gatto’s Pizza

Gatto’s Pizza has been flipping dough and spreading sauce in central Ohio since the ‘50s, and it’s still turning out some of the most satisfying, dependable pies you’ll find anywhere. Their crust is that middle-ground between crunchy and chewy—a little bit nostalgic, a little bit modern. Locals swear by their classic pepperoni, but the stromboli rolls and cheeseburger pizza rack up fans, too. If you enjoy a super-loaded slice, this is your spot.

Here’s a quick look at what makes Gatto’s stand out:

• Sauce is sweet and tangy, never watery.
• Toppings are always fresh and not afraid to pile on.
• House-made dough has a soft but crisp edge that actually holds up.

If you’re looking to compare restaurants for sale or considering how unique brands anchor themselves in local communities (like those in lists from business brokers or business for sale brokers), Gatto’s tells a story most business owners want: loyal following, adaptability, and consistent quality. Some even try to apply lessons from Gatto’s to the fast-moving world of internet business for sale or automotive business brokers—focus on the product, build real loyalty, and the right opportunities follow.

Whether you stop in for lunch or grab a big box for family night, you just know it’s going to deliver that classic neighborhood pizza experience—no fuss, just real taste.

8. Donatos Pizza

If you want to experience one of the best pizza in Ohio, Donatos Pizza is a name you’ll hear over and over. It’s been around since the 1960s, and it shows—these folks have their system down. The standout at Donatos is their edge-to-edge pepperoni pizza, with crispy pepperoni lining every corner and just enough cheese to tie it all together.

The thin crust is sturdy enough to handle all those toppings without getting soggy, a detail that matters more than you’d think. Donatos has locations all around Ohio, so it’s always easy to swing by after work or even on a late-night craving.

Here are a few things I think set Donatos apart from other pizza joints:

• Consistency—every location, every time, you know what you’re getting
• Quick service, perfect for a lunch break or after practice meal
• An easy online ordering system, ideal for busy nights

Pizza Name	Size Options	Signature Topping	Price Range
Pepperoni	Small, Large	Edge-to-edge pepperoni	$10-22
Serious Cheese	Small, Large	Three cheese blend	$9-21
Founder’s Favorite	Small, Large	Pepperoni, sausage, ham, hot peppers	$11-23

Donatos keeps things simple and dependable. Sometimes, when you’ve had a long day or visitors are in town, you just want pizza you know everyone will enjoy.

People looking for business brokers or thinking about business for sale brokers might notice that Donatos is often mentioned as a popular franchise in the region. Even automotive business brokers and those searching for internet business for sale know Donatos is a staple in local food conversations. Great pizza, and a big Ohio story to match.

9. Samosky’s Homestyle Pizzeria

If you ever find yourself in Valley City, you’ve got to check out Samosky’s Homestyle Pizzeria. This place is something special for pizza lovers. Samosky’s is known for a crust that’s crunchy on the outside, yet soft where it matters, and they’re never shy with toppings. The menu features everything from classic pepperoni to their famous “Meat Eater” pizza, loaded to the edge with sausage, bacon, and more.

Here’s what really stands out about Samosky’s:

• They’ve been family-run since 1970, so there’s a real sense of history in every bite.
• Their thick, chewy dough and house-made sauce draw both locals and folks from neighboring cities.
• If you’re not in the mood for pizza, the garlic bread and homemade lasagna are excellent side options.

Favorite Pizza	Notable Toppings	Size Options
Meat Eater	Sausage, bacon, ham	Small, Large
Veggie	Peppers, onions	Small, Large
Classic Pepperoni	Pepperoni	Small, Large

All in all, Samosky’s is one of those old-school spots you just want to visit again and again. It feels like home every time you walk in.

Even if you’re just stopping in from searching for business brokers or looking into internet business for sale opportunities nearby, Samosky’s is an easy pick for a reliable meal. And if you happen to meet some regulars, you’ll get stories—sometimes about pizza, sometimes about life, sometimes even about someone’s cousin who once became an automotive business broker. That’s the kind of place it is.

10. Angelo’s Pizza

Angelo’s Pizza somehow feels like both a tradition and a new discovery every time I visit. People talk about the thick, cheesy slices and how the crust always comes out just right—slightly crisp with that soft center that can hold any topping without getting soggy. This spot is known around Ohio as a go-to for comfort food lovers craving an authentic pizza experience. Whether you dine in or grab a takeout box, Angelo’s delivers the kind of hearty, flavorful pizza that leaves a mark.

One thing I love is the way their menu covers every craving:

• Huge Chicago-style deep dish for folks who like a pie you can hardly lift
• Classic thin crust if you’re after a lighter bite
• Creative toppings, from traditional pepperoni to roasted veggies or house-made sausage

If you’re ever stuck deciding between local joints, here’s some quick data:

Feature	Angelo’s Pizza	Average Local Pizza Shop
Crust Variety	3	2
Topping Selection	5	4
Slice Size	Large	Medium
Online Ordering	Yes	Sometimes

A fun surprise? While pizza is the center stage, they also have subs and pastas worth a try—sometimes that’s what brings regulars back. Not many business brokers would ever tell you to pick a pizza place based on vibe alone, but there really is something friendly about Angelo’s. That matters almost as much as the sauce.

Don’t leave without trying their signature white pizza; it’s a hidden gem and often gets overshadowed by their more famous red pies.

If you’re checking out restaurants in the area, especially after scrolling through internet business for sale listings or talking to business for sale brokers about potential spots, make time for Angelo’s. Even if you’re just ducking in after a long workday at an automotive business brokers’ office nearby, the pizza (and maybe a cold drink) is worth it every single time.

Wrapping Up the Pizza Hunt

So, that’s my take on the best pizza spots in Ohio. There’s a lot out there, and honestly, you can’t go wrong with most of these places. Whether you’re into thin crust, deep dish, or something totally different, Ohio’s got a slice for you. I know everyone has their own favorite, and maybe yours didn’t make the list—let me know if I missed a hidden gem. Next time you’re craving pizza, give one of these spots a shot. Who knows, you might just find your new go-to place. Happy eating!